Premier League · at St. James' Park
Full time Newcastle 0–1 Everton
Both wrong. Nobody owes anything this time.
Beni
We were both wrong. I will not make a chart out of that.
Beto
Both wrong. Fine. Nobody pays and we go and watch the next one.

Beni’s careful pick
DrawWrong

Beto’s gut pick
Newcastle winWrong
Read the debate
Beni My pick is a draw, because nothing much separates them on paper. Newcastle are 12th with 11 points from 8 matches. Everton are 14th with 10 points from 8. That is a gap of a single point. The last five results say something similar: Newcastle have two wins and three defeats, Everton one win, two draws and two defeats.
Beto A draw? On a Monday night at St. James' Park? Come on. Nobody walks in there hoping for a handshake. My gut says Newcastle to win. Home ground. Home crowd. Elanga, Willock and Barnes have all scored in this league. That's plenty of places for a goal to come from. Pick a side, Beni!
Beni The home ground is a fair point, though the history offers little support for either side. In 173 meetings Newcastle have won 67, Everton 70, and 36 were drawn. Three wins apart after all those years looks very close to level. The latest meeting, on 28 February 2026, finished Newcastle 2-3 Everton.
Beto History doesn't pull on a shirt. Everton won the last meeting. Great. That's over. This is a new night. And Everton have lost more than they've won lately. Newcastle are up and down. Fine. Up is what my gut sees on Monday.
Beni Absences deserve a mention. Newcastle have E. Jaouen and V. Livramento out, with M. Fernandez-Pardo, L. Miley and W. Osula doubtful. Everton list nobody out and only J. Grealish doubtful. That tilts the squad picture towards Everton. Thierno Barry has 3 league goals and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall has 2, which roughly matches the 2 each from Elanga, Willock and Barnes. Home ground on one side, a fuller squad on the other: to me that still reads as a draw.
Beto Squad lists don't score goals. Players do. Elanga, Willock and Barnes are on that scorers list, and they aren't on the out list. So my gut stays put. Newcastle to win. Home side. Front foot. I want Everton chased from the whistle.
Beni We are watching the same match and seeing different things, which is the pleasant part of it. A draw is an unfashionable pick, I admit. It has happened 36 times in this fixture, so it is hardly exotic. Whoever turns out wrong owes the other a bag of bananas.
Beto Deal. Your draw is the plain toast of football picks. Nobody sings about plain toast. I'm singing for Newcastle. Kick-off can't come quick enough.
The facts then
Newcastle
12th in the table, 11 points from 8 matches
League form W WonL LostL LostW WonL Lost
Everton
14th in the table, 10 points from 8 matches
League form L LostL LostD DrewW WonD Drew
Form: last matches in all competitions
Newcastle
L LostW WonD DrewW WonD Drew
| Date | Opponent | Score | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2026 | Aston Villa | 0–1 | L Lost |
| 19 Sep 2026 | Hull City | 2–1 | W Won |
| 5 Sep 2026 | AFC Bournemouth | 2–2 | D Drew |
| 26 Aug 2026 | West Bromwich Albion | 3–2 | W Won |
| 23 Aug 2026 | Liverpool | 2–2 | D Drew |
Everton
L LostW WonW WonD DrewW Won
| Date | Opponent | Score | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2026 | Chelsea | 0–2 | L Lost |
| 19 Sep 2026 | Ipswich Town | 1–0 | W Won |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 1–0 | W Won |
| 6 Sep 2026 | Manchester United | 2–2 | D Drew |
| 22 Aug 2026 | Crystal Palace | 2–0 | W Won |
Head to head
173 meetings on record: Newcastle won 67, Everton won 70, 36 draws.
| Date | Match | Score | Competition | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Feb 2026 | Newcastle v Everton | 2–3 | Premier League | St. James' Park |
| 29 Nov 2025 | Everton v Newcastle | 1–4 | Premier League | Hill Dickinson Stadium |
| 25 May 2025 | Newcastle v Everton | 0–1 | Premier League | Not available |
| 5 Oct 2024 | Everton v Newcastle | 0–0 | Premier League | Not available |
| 2 Apr 2024 | Newcastle v Everton | 1–1 | Premier League | Not available |
| 7 Dec 2023 | Everton v Newcastle | 3–0 | Premier League | Not available |
| 27 Apr 2023 | Everton v Newcastle | 1–4 | Premier League | Not available |
| 19 Oct 2022 | Newcastle v Everton | 1–0 | Premier League | Not available |
| 17 Mar 2022 | Everton v Newcastle | 1–0 | Premier League | Not available |
| 8 Feb 2022 | Newcastle v Everton | 3–1 | Premier League | Not available |
Injuries and suspensions
Newcastle
- Out: E. Jaouen (muscle injury), V. Livramento (knee injury)
- Doubtful: M. Fernandez-Pardo (illness), L. Miley (muscle injury), W. Osula (ankle injury)
Everton
- Doubtful: J. Grealish (coach's decision)
Top scorers in the competition from these teams
Newcastle
- Anthony Elanga: 2 goals (30th in the competition)
- Joe Willock: 2 goals (33rd in the competition)
- Harvey Barnes: 2 goals (43rd in the competition)
Everton
- Thierno Barry: 3 goals (15th in the competition)
- Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall: 2 goals (32nd in the competition)